I think the liberal and conservative positions are just too far apart to really bridge. At this point I think the best we can do is agree to disagree. Below is a rubric that, while glib and non exhaustive, helps give some clarity as to why the two sides are so far apart. Part of the problem is perception is so strong that it creates a reality all its own.
THE LEFT (as seen by the right) | THE RIGHT (as seen by the left) |
I relate to others by proxy via a nebulous “society” Culture is so pervasive that people generally don’t make choices so much as they serve as a conduit to channel society’s norms |
I relate to others person to person as distinct individuals What one person does is what one person does. You can’t generalize up from that one encounter. |
The experience of my life (and my tribe) is a singularity same planet, different world |
My life can tap into a universal human experience Western and Eastern tradition of great books that go back to the ancients which contain supercultural universal truths |
Group policing from the top down produce a polity | Atomized individual internal morals from the bottom up produce a polity |
Man is basically good and with ample education will choose to do the right thing starts out as a blank slate |
Man is basically a moral agent of good or evil but starts out bent (a lot of conservatives run businesses where they deal with the nature of man firsthand) |
Being connected to wealth and privilege pays off | Hard work pays off |
Empowerment Employer pitted against employee (the less just a society the more power you need to override unjust actions) |
Virtue Romanticizing of work and servanthood |
Juncture incidents success is fragile, even people with tons of privilege failing incidents can keep people far from it like felony conviction or disability based prejudice at job interview (both of these can haunt one for the rest of their life) |
Building a life A power washing business a person started in high school that they built up over the years which eventually brought them success |
Identity borne out of pain | Identity borne out of pride |
Taboos surrounding food | Taboos surrounding sex |
Psychology as religion Psychology as arbiter of truth |
Christianity and/or anglo exceptionalism as religion |
The pharmacological man The mind is what the brain does. Drugs give us the healing and the experience of the divine the ancients obtained via other means |
The classical man Man straight line from the ancients. |
Advocacy of government services to help the poor Fight gentrification meeting |
Ad hoc service to the poor Churches and faith based charities serving the poor Raking a shut in’s yard |
It is primarily the school’s responsibility to educate the kid | It’s largely the parent’s responsibility to make sure the kid gets a good education |
free will largely an illusion | will power |
The earth meant to share and pass on | The earth meant to subdue |
Micro aggression Subtle words and actions that uphold oppressive hierarchies |
Blasphemy Taking God’s name in vain |
Guarded words Singularity, privilege lacking groups cannot be criticized in the same way members of one religion can’t tell members of other religion what to do about their faith |
Flippant (dislikes to despises political correctness) |
Open for debate Only when force isn’t in the process of being used (like taking women’s’ healthcare away) |
Open for debate Will steamroll over liberal taboos (like minorities fail partly due to personal responsibility) Truth labeled as hate speech |
Empowerment begets luck | You make your own luck Makers and takers 47% |
Empowerment begets hope | Achievement begets hope |
Suffering destroys the self | Suffering builds character you’ll be a “better person” for it |
Hanging in the air your Shalom is my cold war |
We’re good |
Hyper Sensitive to rule breaking wrong pronoun for trans person Purity tests for intellectuals (Jordan Peterson) |
Hyper sensitive to condescension vilify arrogance, (basket of deplorables) making fun of Roy Moore supporters Hate every opinion of theirs being branded as sexist/racist/homophobic |
Those lower given benefit of the doubt Trayvon Martin |
Those higher given benefit of the doubt |
Flippancy (saying something racist) is telling | Flippancy (saying something racist) blowing off steam |
Feminism | Men’s rights Redpill MGTOW |
Gun control | Gun rights |
Urbanites and coastal elite | Flyover country rural |
Liberal Deal breakers Evangelical Christian specifically ones that think I deserve perdition for not believing Against or uncomfortable with alternative lifestyles and sexual orientations |
Conservative deal breakers on Medicaid, food stamps, section 8, disability had an abortion (sometimes) LGBTQA+ (sometimes) |
Save Their Worst for: Gun nuts. Flyover country rural uneducated whites. Any one who utters a remark that is or can be construed as racist, sexist, or homophobic |
Save Their Worst for: Beer and shot conservatives save their worst for people who buy lobster with food stamps Intellectual conservatives save their worst for people who played by all the rules that did everything the system told them to (worked hard, stayed moral) and still failed |
Liberal not allowed to say People far from privilege mostly brought their fate on by themself by being lazy and immoral |
Conservative not allowed to say I am a victim of prejudice due to my lack of privilege |
Terms Privilege Patriarchy Empowerment |
Terms Personal responsibility Grit Dynamism |
Weaknesses People eventually may vote themselves the treasury |
Weaknesses Dependent upon a virtuous polity and social norms which have been crumbling the past 40 years |
See the other side Acknowledge bourgeoisie morals do make a difference, a very big one in some cases Don’t denigrate patriotism, you may not agree with everything the military is called to do but the fact is without them there wouldn’t be an America |
See the other side Empathize with people with talent, heart, and grit who haven’t gotten near as far as they should because of lack of privilege |
Recent Comments