No Goodness, No Hope

It seems that society has shifted where you used to have to give an answer for the hope that was in you (1 Peter 3:15) where now it’s expected of you that you give an answer for the hope you don’t have. For me there is a real good reason for this because I have a visible physical disability which makes my every interaction with the world an incursion.

Yes they have gotten rid of those ugly laws of the early 20th century but don’t think things have improved much as people would like you to believe My whole life I have been rejected for jobs because of my disability and it’s gotten worse in the past three years. In fact one recruiter even blatantly said I need to somehow make people comfortable with my physical disability (as, as I already understood at the time, it was an incursion on the abled world). A subsequent interview I brought up my visual impairment about three quarters of the way through the interview and they were like, “we thought you couldn’t see”. At least they were honest.

I’m grateful for the Black Lives Matter chant, “no justice, no peace”, but I’d like to add to that, “no goodness, no hope”. I have found no goodness in the vocational world so am under no obligation to hope. People in power strongly dislike the fact that a lot of us are hopeless because hopelessness by definition means that something in the environment has to change in order to restore hope. Asking for goodness in the wasteland of late stage capitalism is just too much of an ask.

To take it further modern psychology’s imperative to hope makes even less sense than Christianity’s. With Christianity you ideally have a supportive community around you and (if you have the capacity to believe it) a good thing coming in the afterlife. Modern psychology (which is the primary driver of late stage capitalism) gives an imperative to hope without giving an imperative to virtue. People need to pay into the system via virtue to be able to withdraw from it in the form of hope. Goodness is what germinates hope, when there isn’t goodness people still want to be seen as good so they still give you the imperative to hope and trust. But this just does more harm than good as you are just immobilized by the blowback of shitty people.

Helping professionals generally have empathy but they can’t put them selves in the shoes of the average businessman who will be much more judgmental than them when it comes time to give jobs. Because if this they mistakenly believe you have more hope than you actually do.

Is Man Basically Good?

I’ve gotten a lot of flack from liberals for not believing man is basically good. My experience has shown that a good portion of people are shitty when you need them most. Of course with all my pathologies I’m not one that generally attracts good people in the first place. Good people are like castles, they are generally moated and won’t let you in unless you have a lot to offer.

I think the battle verses good and evil is one each one has to fight within our selves. Most of us actually do OK so the statement that most people are good is true, but people extrapolate that to assume that man is basically good and that doesn’t hold water. This whole thing about abolishing the police is absolutely ridiculous. Five percent of the population commits 90% of the crime and these bad apples will run rampant should you dial back the policing of them.

I’m don’t hold a Calvinist view believing in total depravity but I understand that back in the olden days when you had a society that wasn’t so heavily policed you had to get people to behave and make their morality internal and the stick does a better job with that than the carrot. But I don’t think man is as good as modern psychology makes us out to be. I think that’s largely because psychology draws upon the experience of upper class people in developed countries who have generally been in a place of law and order and relative comfort.

Modern Psychology and Men

It is heartbreaking to see the rise of deaths of despair by men without college degrees who just can’t hack it in our modern system. Psychology claims to have the solution and I think it can be of limited help but there is something intractable about men’s problems which it can’t fully address:

Men are planners so calls to live in the moment to beat back despair don’t work well. Psychologists say focus on the now, the dot on the timeline and glean everything positive and calming from the dot. But it’s inborn in men to be scanning the horizon, taking in the whole timeline. If the whole timeline brings about fear and despair then that’s what men are going to feel. Traditional western religion focused on the whole timeline being redemptive (as there was heaven in the end and everything would be made new) as opposed to pop culture Buddhism which focuses on concentrating only on the present moment. Men worked better with a timeline that brought about hope but the prosperity gospel has seeped into modern Christianity so much so that if you don’t have money (like a lot of these men dying of despair) then you aren’t welcome to the church anymore.

Self love manifests itself differently in men than it does in women. For men self love is the tip of the iceberg while dignity is the larger mass that you don’t see. Men love themselves when they live a life that warrants it. A life where they possess dignified work. Dignified work is a load bearing post in a man’s psyche. Take this out and the whole edifice comes crashing down. Modern psychology likes to psychologize men’s situations, for example saying loser men aren’t getting dates because they don’t have “self confidence”. Well duh, of course they don’t have self love because their self love is tied to their dignity and a man does not possess innate worth aside from what he brings to the table. Men receive mixed messages from culture about this which just makes navigating the world more tricky. Men dying of despair often don’t have jobs that provide a living wage and as a result lose everything else.

When men talk about their problems it is often less cathartic. This is because a lot of men’s depression manifests itself as anger so when you exhume it it’s like opening up a Pandora’s Box. When men open up they often make an emotional mess which people around them are often not equipped or even willing to deal with. Therapists can help with this but the most important thing is the rapport with them rather than the type of therapy being used. However, men often need hours of just being with people before they open up, they often can’t do so on cue. That’s partially why men get a lot out of hunting and fishing, just being on the lake with a buddy cracking open a beer and shooting the breeze.

Men need father figures. No therapist, app, or book can replace this. Men have unique needs just like women and they need strong mature male mentors to look up to and emulate. If one is lucky they had a good or good enough relationship with their father. It is heartbreaking that so many boys are growing up without a father, all they have is their mother and modern psychology. Research has shown that boys that grow up without a father do much worse in life than women that do so and this is one of the reasons men are falling behind women on almost every metric. The gospel of the atomized individual is a lie, for males without fathers and even males with them it is important to find more mature male role models that will invest in them. This is easier said than done because modern psychology has told everyone to put them selves first and people shouldn’t selflessly invest in others. But the current system isn’t working out for men and the deaths of despair attest to this.

Agency

Those in power like to psychologize situations to give those in powerless situations the illusion of agency. For example saying a person isn’t finding a job because they have a bad attitude. This is pinning something out of their control (finding a job) on them to make it seem like they have more control over the situation than they really do. Considering modern psychology is a tool of oppressing those on the bottom this doesn’t surprise me a bit.

Empathy Article

Empathy is on the decline. This may not be as bad as it sounds

When we feel empathy, we typically give power to another person or institution. We identify with — and internalize — their point of view. In extreme cases, this can lead to the kind of loss of self we associate with Stockholm Syndrome, where a hostage over-identifies with his or her captor. Empathy makes us vulnerable to subordinating ourselves to others, especially to those in power.

Of course the lack of empathy hurts those without power the most because when you do have power those under you are forced to empathize with you or be crushed.

Hope Comes From Crumbs

If there isn’t a trail of crumbs I can surmise there is no bread. Been looking for a job since September with nothing positive since October. I’m supposed to believe that if I keep at it something good will happen but I don’t believe it. Not because my mind is in a “unhealthy” depressive state but I just see no evidence to believe otherwise, my job coach is a good guy but we are using indeed which is just shooting resumes in a black hole. Hope and conjecture are not diametrically opposed to each other. A little conjecture has to leak into hope in order for it to be self sustaining and vice versa. Even people who hope in vain for all kinds of crazy happy outcomes get the placebo response form said hope.

People who claim the future is going to be so bright if you just keep your head down and then none of this brightness shines in the present moment are just stringing you along. What else would people stringing you on tell you? That would never tell you to be hopeless because hopelessness is empowering because that indicates that something in your environment is going to have to change in order to restore hope. The only thing that really begets hope is empowerment because that allows you to counter whatever self serving action others are going to put you through.

Self Love

From: The Boy Who Was Raised as a Dog: And Other Stories from a Child Psychiatrist’s Notebook

For years mental health professionals taught people that they could be psychologically healthy without social support, that “unless you love yourself, no one else will love you”. Women were told that they didn’t need men, and vice versa. People without any relationships were believed to be as healthy as those who had many. These ideas contradict the fundamental biology of human species: we are social mammals and could never have survived without deeply interconnected and interdependent human contact. The truth is, you cannot love yourself unless you have been loved and are loved. The capacity to love cannot be built in isolation.

Depression’s Causes

Great article on depression and basic income:

Why? If depression is primarily—as we have been led to believe by pharmaceutical company marketing campaigns—a problem with our brain chemistry, this makes no sense. The brains of the people of Dauphin did not suddenly evolve in those three years. But the World Health Organization, the leading medical body in the world, has explained: “Mental health is produced socially. The presence or absence of mental health is above all a social indicator and requires social as well as individual solutions.” In reality, depression and anxiety are produced by a broad range of factors. Some are biological—but many are social and psychological.

Masculinity Toxic By Default

OK now the American Psychological Association has declared traditional masculinity toxic  (and so my love affair with modern psychology continues).

So you’are saying men have to show emotion.  But emotion is like an oil well, something very hard to selectively control.  Society wants men to show emotion but only when it comprises a feat of strength (like emotionally supporting a partner).  At all other times they must suppress it.  I have had at least one woman cut me off when I was vulnerable with her about my mental health struggles.  

I am weak which is why men and women don’t respect me.  I can remember one time going out on a paddle boat with an autism group I helped run and melting down when I didn’t think we could paddle back to shore.  It didn’t garner me any respect with the other people in that boat.  Men are expected to be courageous and that necessitates suppressing emotion.  It is disingenuous for modern psychology to label something that has helped men survive and mate for millennia toxic.

Malcare WordPress Security